Tito’s NY Style Pizzeria in Greenville has an awesome pepperoni pizza.

by Jami Mullikin on November 3, 2011

Tito’s NY Style Pizzeria
2018 N. Pleasantburg Drive
Greenville, SC 29609 USA


There’s no denying that Tito brought the best NY Style pizza to town.

There’s a battle in Greenville over the best NY-style pizza and it is most often between Tito’s and Pizza City. But considering Tito started Pizza City, I think he takes the trophy. However, Tony’s Pizzeria is building a pretty good following so it looks like a three way race. Rumor has it, Tony used to work for Tito. So whether everyone agrees or not, Tito brought the best pizza to town.

Tito’s Pepperoni Pizza is awesome and you simply can’t go wrong there. The crust is thin and floppy like most NY style pizza and the recipe is an even balance of sauce and cheese. They keep it simple without additional seasonings and it is consistent every time. I added a little red pepper and Parmesan to mine to give it a little kick and it has a flavor that takes me right back to NYC. If you haven’t paid Tito a visit, I highly recommend it.

Tito's Restaurant Pizzeria on Urbanspoon

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

W. Jason Griffith November 3, 2011 at 3:14 am

Since I live in between both Tito’s and Pizza City, I can say that Tito’s hands down. I remember the one time that I tried Pizza City, I thought that the pizza tasted salty! Hence, if I liked it, I’ve had many opportunities to go back, but keep going to Tito’s!


Jami Mullikin November 3, 2011 at 3:20 am

I agree but will have to go give it a shot to write a post on it. The vibe at Tito’s is definitely better but I think I still see Pizza City as a Hardee’s because that is what it was there when I was a kid.


Mary Ellen Grom November 3, 2011 at 12:44 pm

Never been to either…think I’m going for Tit’s first. Thanks for the suggestion!


Mark Cohee December 16, 2011 at 2:31 am

Jami-I name you the Grand Poohba of Pizza. As a fellow foodie, The Fat Guy with a Little Fork has to agree with you about Tito’s. Probably the best pizza in G-Vegas. My favorite is the italian sauage. That fact that its not sliced or crumbled but shaved..I mean come on. Who does that? Tito-On behalf of us all…..THANK YOU.
The Fat Guy is Out!


Rachael Holt December 29, 2012 at 9:14 pm

Hands down the best pizza in Greenville. My fiance and I eat here once a week and find the consistency, friendliness of the staff, and food is unrivaled by many restaurants out there. It is our favorite spot and we can’t get enough. Their subs, salads, pizza and lasagna can’t be beat! It breaks are hearts when they are closed for the holiday season. Titos how we love thee…


jmadmin January 5, 2013 at 4:18 pm

Thanks for the comment! Yeah they are closed on mondays to :( It is great pizza and the authentic, Italian, family-owned vibe is pretty cool.


Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: